• editor.aipublications@gmail.com
  • Track Your Paper
  • Contact Us
  • ISSN: 2456-8791

International Journal Of Forest, Animal And Fisheries Research(IJFAF)

The influence of the foodscape on quaking aspen stand condition and use by ungulates

Kristen Y. Heroy , Samuel B. St. Clair , Paul C. Rogers , Juan J. Villalba

Download | Downloads : 6 | Total View : 2719

DOI: 10.22161/ijfaf.2.2.2

Journal : International Journal Of Forest, Animal And Fisheries Research(IJFAF)


In order to study the effects of herbivory on plant communities, we determined whether the types and concentrations of chemicals present in different aspen (Populus tremuloides Michx.) stands and understories, i.e., the foodscape, are associated with aspen use by elk (Cervus elaphus L.) and with aspen regeneration and recruitment. Transects were established in aspen stands with high, medium, and low regeneration levels (N=5 locations/regeneration level; ranging from 2,331 m to 2,724 m in elevation) in Wolf Creek Ranch in northern Utah. Using non-metric multidimensional scaling (NMDS) ordination and regression analyses, we examined the relationships between aspen regeneration, recruitment, elk presence, browsing, and other landscape elements with the foodscape (e.g., biomass and chemical composition of the understory and chemical defenses of juvenile aspen trees). The foodscape was affected by elevation and canopy height but it did not explain aspen use or indicators of aspen resilience. Our findings suggest that foodscapes of lower nutrient content–occurring at lower elevations under drier climatic conditions–are more likely to foster aspen stands with less forb and grass understory, and thus lower nutritional biomass. Nevertheless, the extent of the decline in the availability of nutrients in the understory did not appear to influence aspen browsing or indicators of aspen resilience. Future research should focus on exploring the influence of additional–and more contrasting–gradients of chemical availability in the landscape on aspen use by herbivores.

Browsing, Elk, Phenolic glycosides, Plant secondary compounds, Preference.

[1] PR Atsatt, DJ O’Dowd, “Plant defense guilds,” Science, 1976, 193(4247):24-29.
[2] E Baraza, R Zamora, JA Hódar, “Conditional outcomes in plant–herbivore interactions: neighbours matter,” Oikos, 2006, 113:148-56.
[3] JJ Villalba, FD Provenza, “Foraging in chemically diverse environments: Energy, protein, and alternative foods influence ingestion of plant secondary metabolites by lambs,” J Chem Ecol., 2005, 31(1):123-38.
[4] KR Searle, NT Hobbs, IJ Gordon, “It’s the “Foodscape”, not the landscape: Using foraging behavior to make functional assessments of landscape condition,” Isr J Ecol Evol., 2007, 53:297-316.
[5] KY Heroy, SB St. Clair, EA Burritt, JJ Villalba, “Nutrients and secondary compounds influence trembling aspen (Populus tremuloides) intake by sheep,” J Chem Ecol., 2017, 43(8):817-830.
[6] KY Heroy, SB St. Clair, EA Burritt, SL. Durham, JJ Villalba, “Nutritional state and secondary compounds influence trembling aspen (Populus tremuloides) intake by lambs,” Appl Anim Behav Sci, Accepted.
[7] DW Bailey, JE Gross, EA Laca, LR Rittenhouse, MB Coughenour, DM Swift, PL Sims, “Mechanisms that result in large herbivore grazing distribution patterns,” J Range Manage., 1996, 49:386-400.
[8] FJ Perez-Barberia, DM Walker, IJ Gordon, “Sex differences in feeding behaviour at feeding station scale in Soay sheep (Ovies aries),” Behaviour, 2004, 141: 999–1020.
[9] FD Provenza, JJ Villalba, “Foraging in domestic herbivores: Linking the internal and external milieu,” in Feeding in Domestic Vertebrates: From Structure to function, V.L. Bels, Ed., Oxfordshire, UK: CABI Publ, 2006, pp. 210-240.
[10] AM MacFarlane, G Coulson, “Sexual segregation in western grey kangaroos: testing alternative evolutionary hypotheses,” J Zool., 2007, 273: 220–228.
[11] J Taillon, SD Cote, “Social rank and winter forage quality affect aggressiveness in white-tailed deer fawns,” Anim Beh., 2007, 74: 265–275.
[12] RL Senft, MB Coughenour, DW Bailey, LR Rittenhouse, OE Sala, DM Swift, “Large herbivore foraging and ecological hierarchies,” BioScience, 1987, 37:789-799.
[13] MS Smith, “Modelling: three approaches to predicting how herbivore impact is distributed in rangelands,” New Mexico State Univ. Agr Exp Sta Res Rep, 1988, pp. 628.
[14] CE Kay, “Is aspen doomed?” J Forest., 1997, 95(5): 4–11.
[15] CA White, MC Feller, S Bayley, “Predation risk and the functional response of elk-aspen herbivory,” Forest Ecol Manage., 2003, 181:77-97.
[16] BE Jones, DF Lile, KW Tate, “Cattle selection for aspen and meadow vegetation: implications for restoration,” Range Ecol Manage., 2011, 64:625–632.
[17] RL Lindroth, SY Hwang, “Diversity, redundancy, and multiplicity in chemical defense systems of aspen,” in Phytochemical diversity and redundancy in ecological interactions, J.T. Romeo, J.A. Saunders, and P. Barbosa, Eds., New York: Plenum Press, 1996, pp. 25-56.
[18] WH Romme, MG Turner, LL Wallace, JS Walker, “Aspen, Elk, and Fire in Northern Yellowstone Park,” Ecology, 1995, 76(7):2097-2106.
[19] T Myking, F Bøhler, G Austrheim, EJ Solberg, “Life history strategies of aspen (Populus tremula L.) and browsing effects: a literature review,” Forestry, 2011, 84(1):61-71.
[20] FD Provenza, JJ Villalba, JP Bryant, “Foraging by herbivores: Linking the biochemical diversity of plants to herbivore culture and landscape diversity,” in Landscape Ecology and Resource Management, Linking Theory with Practice, JA Bissonette and I Storch, Eds., Washington DC USA: Island Press, 2003, pp. 387-421.
[21] RA Shaw, JJ Villalba, FD Provenza, “Influence of stock density and rate and temporal patterns of forage allocation on the diet mixing behavior of sheep grazing sagebrush steppe,” Appl Anim Beh Sci., 2006, 100(3-4):207-218.
[22] JL Beck, JM Peek, EK Strand, “Estimates of elk summer range nutritional carrying capacity constrained by probabilities of habitat selection,” J Wildlife Manage., 2006, 70(1):283-294.
[23] JJ Villalba, EA Burritt, SB St. Clair, “Aspen (Populus tremuloides Michx.) Intake and Preference by Mammalian Herbivores: the role of plant secondary compounds and nutritional context,” J Chem Ecol., 2014, 40(10):1135-45.
[24] FD Provenza, “Acquired aversions as the basis for varied diets of ruminants foraging on rangelands,” J Anim Sci., 1996, 74(8):2010-2020.
[25] WJ Freeland, DH Janzen, “Strategies in Herbivory by Mammals: The Role of Plant Secondary Compounds,” Am Nat., 1974, 108(961):269-289.
[26] AW Illius, NS Jessop, “Metabolic constraints on voluntary intake in ruminants,” J Anim Sci., 1996, 74:3052–3062.
[27] RL Lindroth, SB St. Clair, “Adaptations of quaking aspen (Populus tremuloides Michx.) for defense against herbivores,” Forest Ecol Manage., 2013, 299:14-21.
[28] PC Rogers, A Jones, J Catlin, J Shuler, A Morris, M Kuhns, “Quaking Aspen in the Residential-Wildland Interface: Elk Herbivory Hinders Forest Conservation,” Nat Area J., 2015, 35(3):416-427.
[29] DA Durham, CB Marlow, “Aspen response to prescribed fire under managed cattle grazing and low elk densities in southwest Montana,” Northwest Sci., 2010, 84:141-150.
[30] MJ Runyon, DB Tyers, BF Sowell, CN Gower, “Aspen Restoration Using Beaver on the Northern Yellowstone Winter Range under Reduced Ungulate Herbivory,” Restor Ecol., 2014, 22(4):555-561.
[31] KJ Marsh, BD Moore, IR Wallis, WJ Foley, “Feeding rates of a mammalian browser confirm the predictions of a ‘foodscape’ model of its habitat,” Oecologia, 2014, 174:873-882.
[32] PC Rogers, SM Landhӓusser, BD Pinno, RJ Ryel, “A Functional Framework for Improved Management of Western North American Aspen (Populus tremuloides Michx.),” Forest Sci., 2014, 60:345-359.
[33] PJ Abraham, “Wolf Creek Ranch Forest Stewardship Plan. Utah Division of Forestry, Fire and State Lands,” Heber City, UT, 2013.
[34] RO Harniss, KT Harper, “Tree dynamics in seral and stable aspen stands of central Utah,” INT-RP-297, USDA, Forest Service, Intermountain Forest and Range Experiment Station, Ogden, Utah, 1982.
[35] WD Shepperd, “A classification of quaking aspen in the central Rocky Mountains based on growth and stand characteristics,” Western Journal of Applied Forestry, 1990, 5:69-75.
[36] N Bunnefeld, JDC Linnell, J Odden, MAJ Van Duijn, R Anderson, “Risk taking by Eurasian lynx (Lynx lynx) in a human-dominated landscape: effects of sex and reproductive status,” J Zool., 2006, 270:31-39.
[37] M O'Brien, PC Rogers, K Mueller, R MacWhorter, A Rowley, B Hopkins, et al, “Guidelines for aspen restoration on the National Forests in Utah,” Western Aspen Alliance, Utah State University, Logan, Utah, 2010.
[38] BE Jones, D Burton, KW Tate, “Effectiveness monitoring of aspen regeneration on managed rangelands,” R5-EM-TP-004, USDA, Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Region, Vallejo, California, 2005.
[39] PC Rogers, CM Mittanck, “Herbivory strains resilience in drought-prone aspen landscapes of the western United States,” J Veg Sci., 2014, 25(2):457-469.
[40] SB St. Clair, PC Rogers, MR Kuhns, “Managing Ungulate Browsing for Sustainable Aspen,” Western Aspen Alliance Briefs #2, Aspen Bibliography, Paper 7313; 2015 [cited 2017 June 01]. Available from: http://digitalcommons.usu.edu/aspen_bib/7313; and https://extension.usu.edu/rangelands/files/uploads/Aspen/StClair-Aspen_Herbivory.pdf
[41] BA Endress, MJ Wisdom, M Vavra, CG Parks, BL Dick, BJ Naylor, J M Boyd, “Effects of ungulate herbivory on aspen, cottonwood, and willow development under forest fuels treatment regimes,” For Ecol Manage., 2012, 276:33-40.
[42] PC Rogers, JA Gale, “Restoration of the iconic Pando aspen clone: emerging evidence of recovery,” Ecosphere, 2017, 8(1):e01661. 10.1002/ecs2.1661.
[43] LR Rittenhouse, FA Sneva, “A technique for estimating big sagebrush production,” J Range Manage., 1977, 30:68-70.
[44] DW Uresk, RO Gilbert, WH Rickard, “Sampling big sagebrush for phytomass,” J Range Manage., 1977, 30:311-314.
[45] MH Andrew, IR Noble, RT Lange, “A non-destructive method for estimating the weight of forage on shrubs,” Australian Rangeland Journal, 1979, 1:225-231.
[46] NV DeByle, “Animal impacts,” in Aspen: Ecology and management in the western United States, N.V. DeByle and R.P. Winoker, Eds., Fort Collins, CO: GTR-RM-119. USDA, Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Forest and Range Experiment Station,1985, pp. 115-123.
[47] EA Burritt, JA Pfister, JC Malechek, “Effect of drying method on the nutritive composition of esophageal fistula forage samples: influence of maturity,” J Range Manage., 1988, 1:346-9.
[48] AOAC, “Official methods of analysis,” 17th edn. Association of official analytical chemists. Perkin Elmer 5300 DV ICP. 710 Bridgeport Avenue, Shelton, CT: Perkin Elmer, 2002.
[49] PJ Van Soest, JB Robertson, BA Lewis, “Methods for dietary fiber, neutral detergent fiber, and nonstarch polysaccharides in relation to animal nutrition,” J Dairy Sci., 1991, 74:3583-3597.
[50] WP Weiss, HR Conrad, NRS Pierre, “A theoretically-based model for predicting total digestible nutrient values of forages and concentrates,” Anim Feed Sci Technol., 1992, 39:95-110.
[51] NRC, “Nutrient requirements of sheep,” 6th edn. Washington: National Academy Press,1985.
[52] RW Swift, “The caloric value of TDN,” J Anim Sci., 1957, 16:753-756.
[53] RL Lindroth, KK Kinney, CL Platz, “Responses of deciduous trees to elevated atmospheric CO2: productivity, phytochemistry, and insect performance,” Ecology, 1993, 74:763-777.
[54] LJ Porter, LN Hrstich, BC Chan, “The conversion of procyanidins and prodelphinidins to cyanidin and delphinidin,” Phytochemistry, 1986, 25:223-230.
[55] A Hagerman, L Butler, “Condensed tannin purification and characterization of tannin-associated proteins,” J Agric Food Chem., 1980, 28:947–952.
[56] JF Oksanen, G Blanchet, M Friendly, R Kindt, P Legendre, D McGlinn, et al., “Vegan: Community Ecology Package,” R package version 2.4-1, 2016 [cited 2016 December 01]. Available from: https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=vegan.
[57] R Core Team, “R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing,” Vienna, Austria, 2013[Cited 2016 May 01] Available from: http://www.R-project.org/.
[58] RStudio Team, “RStudio: Integrated Development for R,” RStudio, Inc., Boston, MA, 2015 [cited 2016 April 01]. Available from: http://www.rstudio.com/
[59] JF Oksanen, G Blanchet, M Friendly, R Kindt, P Legendre, D McGlinn, et al., “Vegan tutorial,” 2016 [cited 2016 December 26]. Available from: https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/vegan/vegan.pdf .
[60] D Sarkar, “Lattice: Multivariate Data Visualization with R,” New York: Springer. ISBN 978-0-387-75968-5; 2008.
[61] SC Wooley, S Walker, J Vernon, RL Lindroth, “Aspen Decline, Aspen Chemistry, and Elk Herbivory: Are They Linked?” Rangelands, 2008, 30(1):17-21.
[62] LM Holeski, SC McKenzie, EL Kruger, JJ Couture, K Rubert‐Nason, RL Lindroth, “Phytochemical traits underlie genotypic variation in susceptibility of quaking aspen (Populus tremuloides) to browsing by a keystone forest ungulate,” J Ecol., 2016, 104:850–863.
[63] WR Hamon. Reynolds Creek, Idaho. Agricultural Research Service Precipitation Facilities and Related Studies, U.S. Dept. Agric ARS. 1971; 41-176.
[64] HJT Meerveld, JJ McDonnell, “On the interrelations between topography, soil depth, soil moisture, transpiration rates and species distribution at the hillslope scale,” Adv Water Resour., 2005, 29:293-310.
[65] J Harte, R Shaw, “Shifting Dominance Within a Montane Vegetation Community: Results of a Climate-Warming Experiment,” Science, 1995, 267(5199):876-880.
[66] MG Turner, WH Romme, RA Reed, GA Tuskan, “Post-fire aspen seedling recruitment across the Yellowstone (USA) Landscape,” Landscape Ecol., 2003, 18:127-140.
[67] T Latva-Karjanmaa, L Suvanto, K Leinonen, H Rita, “Sexual Reproduction of European Aspen (Populus tremula L.) at Prescribed Burned Site: The Effects of Moisture Conditions,” New For., 2006, 31(3):545-558.
[68] SN Martens, DD Breshears, CW Meyer, “Spatial distributions of understory light along the grassland/forest continuum: effects of cover, height, and spatial pattern of tree canopies,” Ecol Model., 2000, 126:79-93.
[69] Lita Nasution, Riahta Corah, Nuraida, Ameilia Zuliyanti Siregar, P.(2018).Effectiveness Trichoderma and Beauveria bassiana on Larvae of Oryctes rhinoceros On Palm Oil Plant (Elaeis Guineensis Jacq.) In Vitro. International Journal of Environment Agriculture and Biotechnology(ISSN: 2456-1878).3(1), 158-169.10.22161/ijeab/3.1.20
[70] Mere, C. U.; Ater, P. I. and Ezihe, J. A. C., P.(2017).Analysis of Profitability and Constraints of Table Egg Production Enterprises in Benue State, Nigeria. International Journal of Environment Agriculture and Biotechnology(ISSN: 2456-1878).2(6), 2936-2943.10.22161/ijeab/2.6.21
[71] DD Breshears, PM Rich, FJ Barnes, K Campbell, “Overstory imposed heterogeneity in solar radiation and soil moisture in a semiarid woodland,” Ecol Appl., 1997, 7:1201-1215.
[72] DD Breshears, JW Nyhan, CE Heil, BP Wilcox, “Effects of woody plants on microclimate in a semiarid woodland: soil temperature and evaporation in canopy and intercanopy patches,” Int J Plant Sci., 1998, 153:425-433.
[73] ME Floyd, “Dioecy in five Pinus edulis populations in the Southwestern United States,” Am Midl Nat., 1983, 110:405–411.
[74] DJ Padien, K Lajtha, “Plant spatial pattern and nutrient distribution in pinyon-juniper woodlands along an elevational gradient in northern New Mexico,” Int J Plant Sci., 1992, 153:425-433.
[75] SN Martens, DD Breshears, CW Meyer, FJ Barnes, “Scales of above- and below-ground competition in a semiarid woodland as detected from spatial pattern,” J Veg Sci., 1997, 8:655-664.
[76] WJ Calder, KJ Horn, SB St. Clair, “Conifer expansion reduces the competitive ability and herbivore defense of aspen by modifying light environment and soil chemistry,” Tree physiol., 2011, 31(6): 582-591.
[77] HY Wan, AC Rhodes, SB St. Clair, “Fire severity alters plant regeneration patterns and defense against herbivores in mixed aspen forests,” Oikos, 2014, 123(12):1479-1488.
[78] TR Randriamanana, A Labola, R Julkunen-Tiitto, “Interactive effects of supplemental UV-B and temperature in European aspen seedlings: Implications of growth, leaf traits, phenolic defense and associated organisms,” Plant Physiol Biochem., 2015, 93:84-93.
[79] PC Rogers, CM Mittanck, “Herbivory strains resilience in drought-prone aspen landscapes of the western United States,” J Veg Sci., 2014, 25(2):457-469.